On January 4, 2013, a month before Pope Benedict resigned, the Italian Central Bank turned the lights off on the entire Vatican. The Vatican no longer had the ability to make any electronic financial transactions. Italian authorities asserted that the Vatican was not in compliance with international money-laundering rules. This was a clear message that put tremendous pressure on Pope Benedict. Part of the pressure, as we now know through public records, some of which will be detailed, was that there were indeed financial corruption and offshore accounts in powerful places within the Catholic Church — forces that would have been opposed to any effort of Pope Benedict to clean it all up.
Among the multiple public revelations, after Benedict resigned, of financial corruption at the Vatican, two stand out as good examples. The first is the prosecution of the Vatican bank’s president for a money-laundering scheme. The Vatican bank president was held responsible for losses of more than 62 million dollars from real estate sales — allegedly involving the selling of Vatican-owned real estate at under-value prices to offshore companies, then reselling the buildings at market rates, allowing the president of the Vatican Bank to allegedly make huge profits from the difference.
The second example is that the Vatican’s senior accountant of real estate was accused of using the Vatican bank to launder money from Vatican properties. The police froze accounts and seized the Vatican accountant’s real estate company and two of his apartments for a total of about 7.3 million dollars. The accountant had lived in a luxury 17-room apartment decorated with original artwork worth 8.1 million dollars. The Vatican accountant denied the money-laundering accusations, saying his 7.3 million dollars had come from “donations.” Police said it came from illegal money-laundering from offshore companies controlled by his friends. The BBC reported that American financial inspectors, appointed by Pope Francis, believe that the senior accountant for the Vatican’s real estate may not have been alone in having used the Vatican bank for money-laundering operations.
Earlier, before the public revelations of the financial corruption, Pope Benedict had appointed Cardinal Versaldi — at the time president of the Prefecture for Economic Affairs of the Holy See — to investigate two of the Church’s largest financial scandals. The first appointment was to the Legionaries of Christ, whose leader, Father Marcial Maciel, as it was publicly revealed later, personally managed an offshore account in Bermuda, where it is estimated that 300 million dollars went through annually. Cardinal Versaldi’s investigation began when Marcial Maciel was removed from his position for sexual abuse — including raping his own children as well as seminarians under his charge. He was also known for financial irregularities, including bribing Vatican officials with envelopes stuffed with money.
The second investigation that Cardinal Versaldi was appointed to, by Benedict, was of the Vatican hospital, the Istituto Dermopatico dell’Immacolata (IDI), where it was reported by Crux that men with bodyguards were taking shoeboxes full of money from the hospital to offshore accounts. Ultimately, in 2016, Italian authorities indicted 40 officers and employees of the IDI on 144 counts of bankruptcy fraud, money-laundering, and embezzlement. The IDI has been in the news recently because the grant-making Papal Foundation, started by former Cardinal McCarrick, had given this hospital 25 million dollars with the direction of one of its board members, Cardinal Wuerl of Washington, D.C., and at the request of Pope Francis. When the donors to the Papal Foundation of the 25 million dollars requested that their money be returned because of the money-laundering problems at the IDI, Pope Francis canceled for the first time his annual meeting with the donors.
There was a Washington, D.C. network connection between Marcial Maciel and the Papal Foundation. Cardinal Farrell, a trustee of the Papal Foundation, had worked for Maciel, and immediately after the Maciel scandal broke, Farrell became Cardinal McCarrick’s Washington, D.C. auxiliary bishop.
Another Papal Foundation board member (there are only nine, and others are notorious) is Cardinal Maida. (Maida constructed the failed 74-million-dollar JPII cultural center in D.C.) Cardinal Maida had also been on the five-member cardinal board that controls the Vatican bank (IOR). This means he was one of a panel of five cardinals directly in charge of the Vatican Bank for the pope. Among other powers that the Cardinal Commission holds is the hiring and firing of Vatican Bank employees and the lay membership board that manages the bank, as well as deciding where to direct the profits of the Vatican Bank, which last year were 31 million dollars.
In 2000, the Vatican carved out the Cayman Islands from its archdiocese in Jamaica and made it a “special mission,” meaning that the Vatican directly controls the Caymans. The Vatican put Cardinal Maida of Detroit in charge — Detroit is 1,600 miles away. It has been reported that the Vatican has offshore accounts in the Cayman Islands.
There is a parallel to the Caymans and offshore accounts: two years earlier, in 1998, the “special mission” of Turks and Caicos was handed over to then-archbishop McCarrick of Newark, New Jersey. There was an offshore account registered in the Bahamas named the “Vatican Estate Corp.” Turks and Caicos is considered part of the larger island chain of the Bahamas. The Bahamas does not allow a private entity to represent itself even in appearance as a nation-state.
The Vatican Estate Corp was started in 1999, less than one year after McCarrick took control of the Caicos. The Vatican Estate Corp was disbanded on January 31, 2001, and McCarrick left Newark and was installed as archbishop of Washington, D.C. on January 3, 2001. McCarrick didn’t have the same pedigree and financial training as Cardinal Maida, but McCarrick was famous for his ability to raise enormous amounts of money for the Church. And, like Maciel, McCarrick was notorious for handing out envelopes stuffed with money to Vatican officials. McCarrick in 1999, the same year the Vatican Estate Corps was formed, put now-bishop Baldacchino from Malta to manage Turks and Caicos. The Turks and Caicos as of today are still a “special mission,” controlled directly by the Vatican and still in control of the Archdiocese of Newark, New Jersey but now controlled by Cardinal Tobin, who is also on the nine-member board of the Papal Foundation. The Turks and Caicos Islands are on a U.S. State Department list for money-laundering and offshore account problems, including problems of child-trafficking .
It’s also known that in 2012, Pope Benedict named the second-in-command at the Vatican City-State, Archbishop Viganò as his new ambassador to the United States. This happened almost immediately after Viganò wrote a letter to Benedict informing him of financial corruption in the Vatican. Viganò, while in Washington, D.C. as nuncio, exposed details of the McCarrick scandal and is now in hiding for fear of his life.
It would turn out that it was Pope Benedict’s last official act to appoint Cardinal Versaldi to investigate the scandal-ridden Vatican hospital that later received a 25-million-dollar grant from the Papal Foundation. It may seem like an inauspicious last act for a pope. But, on January of 2013, the month before Pope Benedict resigned, when the Italian Central Bank closed all Vatican electronic transactions for failure to comply with international money laundering laws, that inauspicious act pointed to the great pressure Pope Benedict was facing. Perhaps now there will be an opportunity to clean it all up.
Chris Caldwell has a law degree from Boston College, an MBA from Johns Hopkins, and an M.A. in philosophical theology from Berkeley. He has taught philosophy courses at two colleges and was a political appointee in the Bush administration from 2000 to 2003.
[…] 1999, the same year Baldacchino was assigned to the mission, McCarrick set up an offshore account called the “Vatican Estate Corp,” which only lasted until 2001, when McCarrick was […]