Browse Our Articles & Podcasts

Book Review: Walking the Road to God by Fr. Lawrence Carney

Walking the Road to God: Why I Left Everything Behind and Took to the Streets to Save Souls
Fr. Lawrence Carney
Caritas Press, 2016
210 pages
$5.99 Kindle; $14.95 Paperback

Walking the Road to God is a moving account of the mission and dream of Fr. Lawrence Carney, a traditional priest serving now as chaplain to the traditional Benedictines of Mary, Queen of Apostles, in Gower, Missouri, and how he began to convert many souls by what he calls the “Hook and Line” method.

The hook is the 12-inch crucifix Fr. Carney carries in his right hand, and the line is the rosary he carries in his left. He began to do this after reading this passage in Louis de Montfort’s True Devotion: “They [the apostles of the end times] shall carry the crucifix in their right hand and the rosary in their left hand.” Immediately, people began to take notice of this gentle-looking man in a black cassock with a crucifix. When someone comes up to Fr. Carney, be it out of curiosity, contempt, or eagerness for spiritual direction, he will talk with the person for a little while. Fr. Carney will give the person a rosary and a pamphlet on how to pray it, as well as inviting him to choose a religious medal from a giant bag he always carries.

Here is a short example of the sort of stories he tells in this delightfully readable book:

While visiting [the soup kitchen] one day, a sister approaches me with a request: “Father, one of the homeless here just lost his sister to a homicide. He is so angry and he is telling us that he is going to kill the man. Could you talk to him?”


I had been praying the Breviarum Romanum. After the sister introduces me to the man, I look him in the face, smile, and pray Psalm 26 in English. My book has the Latin on one side and the English on the other side. As I pray, I notice the living Word of God speaking to is heart. When I finish the Psalm, he takes the breviary from me, looks at the text, closes the book and kisses it. I go to the adoration chapel and ask God to calm his heart so that he will not follow his desire to kill the man who killed his sister.

Fr. Carney, when traveling in Rome, was once asked by an Italian woman whether, if she bought one for him, he would wear the saturno, the traditional wide-brimmed hat of the clergy. He said yes. This wide-brimmed black hat is as much an attraction as his cassock, if not more. Fr. Carney says that nearly every day, someone will say how happy he is to see him in the traditional priestly garb, whether that someone is a practicing or a fallen away Catholic, or even completely secular.

There is nothing fancy or sophisticated here, but rather luminous faith and humility. Fr. Carney shares his ideas, experiences, and plans. The humility and radical charity are contagious: after reading the book in (almost) one sitting, I felt imbued with a desire to bear witness for Christ. We hear a lot about this “witness,” and yet it rarely seems to get off the ground or to attract our attention.

Fr. Carney has it right because he is not witnessing to “beige Catholicism.” He is being a witness to the powerful Faith that brought us through after the fall of Rome, that launched the Crusades, that produced Gregorian chant and the Gothic cathedrals, that yielded the Mass of Ages and a “cloud of witnesses which no man can number.”

Fr. Carney is not content to do this radical but real street evangelization by himself. He is in the process of founding an order called the Canons Regular of Saint Martin. This is how he describes his vision for the order:

Imagine walking by a beautiful monastery, with windows and doors open, the chanting of Solemn Vespers drifting out, incense billowing up to the ceiling, candle bearers standing by the abbot as he preaches the Gospel. Imagine how the soul, at this sight, would leave the ugly world behind and enter, as through a gate of heaven, a Gothic Church, not in the stale atmosphere of a museum, but a church filled with dozens of cannons regular in black robes, giving honor and glory in the Divine Offices day and night. In times past, it has been a particular charism of Canons Regular to offer a place for beautiful liturgies. If we receive this charism as described, people would come in and think, “I just entered the twelfth century, and I love it!” Beauty like this transcends time, and that is why these rich expressions of faith are just as relevant today as they were hundreds of years ago.

The Canons Regular I envision would follow the Rule of St. Augustine. The charisms of the Canons Regular would fall between that of fully active parish priest and fully contemplative monks in a country monastery. The Canon Regular prays in the morning with Gregorian chant and says or attends two Masses in the city monastery. In the afternoon he would go out, like St. Martin, on the apostolate, to convert a culture steeped in darkness. The Canon Regular would come back for Vespers, a meal with table reading, recreation, Compline and monastic silence.

I find this vision of half-contemplative, half-active monk-priests attractive. This idea is like that of the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer (or “Transalpine Redemptorists”), only on a daily instead of yearly basis. (The Redemptorists work for half the year at a parish and spend the other half at a remote island monastery.) The Canons Regular of Saint Martin would fill a certain gap in the spectrum of traditional orders, as there are no other orders or communities, to my knowledge, that have this wonderful combination of monastic contemplation and mendicant-style preaching.

What we see in Fr. Carney and his vision for the future is a robust example of the New Evangelization by traditional Catholic priests. Quite apart from its vagueness, “New Evangelization” often carries a hint of novelty, of rupture from the past. Yet whenever Pope John Paul II and Benedict XVI spoke of it, they did not fail to say that people today need the unchanging truths of the Gospel proclaimed in new ways and with new means. Ironically, after over fifty years of a now graying if not baldheaded modernism, what Fr. Carney is doing – walking the streets in cassock and saturno, with crucifix and rosary, preaching Christ the King and His holy Catholic Church – is radically new and surprisingly appealing. Whether this appeal is due to the strangeness factor or something much deeper – namely, a perennial vitality in the message and the traditional ways of delivering it – is perhaps hard to say, but there can be no doubt that “the old ways,” for a long time despised and rejected, are proving themselves highly effective today, in a postmodern world desperately in need of meaning to overcome nihilism, tradition to overcome rootless autonomy, friendship to overcome isolation, and beauty to overcome suffocating banality.

In the powerful simplicity of his stories, in the strong triple-cord – traditional liturgy, devotions, and apologetics – of his life, Fr. Carney demonstrates that the old certainties and the magnificent prayer of the Church do, in fact, respond to modern man’s needs – that same “modern man” for whose sake Catholic churchmen in the 1960s and 1970s claimed they had to turn everything upside-down.

The failure of that experiment is too obvious now to gainsay. Fr. Carney is only one of many today picking up the lost thread and reconnecting with the Catholicism of our forefathers and of the future. An immense benefit of this book, therefore, is that, over and above giving us an inspiring account of the daily work of a street apostle, it imparts a vision of what traditionally minded Catholics ought to be doing in order to engage the modern world better and, at the same time, what all Catholics ought to reintegrate into their own attempts to evangelize.

By the way, Fr. Carney is not just daydreaming about the Gothic church – he has the use of one in Kansas City, where he would like to found the order! But to hear the full story, you will need to read the book.


Correction: we originally reported that Fr. Carney owns a church in Kansas City. He in fact is using a church that is owned by another Catholic organization. The article has been corrected.

16 thoughts on “Book Review: Walking the Road to God by Fr. Lawrence Carney”

  1. Always enjoy reading your articles! Very pleased to learn of this book! Shall buy it for a family read-a-loud 🙂

    God bless!

  2. I would like the good Father to make a pilgrimage to the heart of Times Square in NYC on a Broadway matinee Wednesday. He’d garner thousands of souls and not have to move an inch! 🙂 What a great man, and I get a strong feeling he has a blessed and charming sense of humor in his work. How could he not? “Angels fly because they take themselves lightly,” the saying goes. From just this (very good) book review one has the sense Father never bears the cross of thinking he is the Worker of the wonders he is part of, but simply the chosen means, and therefore the wonders overflow. That is true humility. Cannot wait to buy this book! Thank you.

    • Sometimes the biggest, most important, most noticed place is not the place that God has in mind. Why was Jesus born in Bethlehem? Why not Jerusalem, or Rome, or Constantinople? Those cities were surely more important. Jesus surely could have reached more people if he had been there instead of Galilee. Sometimes the biggest, most important, most noticed place is not the place that God has in mind.

  3. Good review. I hope to read his book. Fr. Carney is an excellent priest.

    One point, however…

    I do not know of any “Gothic Church…right in the middle of Kansas City” that Fr. Carney owns. Fr. Carney is based out of St. Joseph, which is an hour north of Kansas City. There is a Gothic church that was a diocesan parish until it was closed in the early 1990’s. At one time, Fr. Carney was hoping to acquire it, but I think those plans fell through. At an hour north of Kansas City, and with quite a bit of rural area between the two places, I’m not sure I’d call that “right in the middle of Kansas City.”

  4. Part of this message is how important dress is to ‘witness.’ If Father is attracting attention with his traditional priestly garb, we too can inspire others (or at least make them LOOK) by modest clothing. Not just at Mass which would be obvious, but at the Mall. Skirts and blouses for women, shirts and pants for men. Who cares what ‘the world’ looks like? Are we not called, as is Father, to be different, and witness?

    He is doing wonderful work just by walking around…we can too.

  5. Wow! At the same moment our putative spiritual leaders are in Orlando talking about how joyful and newly evangelistic they are, this man is actually bringing souls to Christ and the Church for which He sacrificed Himself for using the approach the Apostles used – preaching Christ crucified (1 Cor 1:23), and doing so in complete simplicity. It also appears that he is making the point, indirectly at least, that renewal will come from neither the liberals nor the “conservatives” but from the authentic Apostolic Tradition.

  6. The church where I was baptized at was the Holy Redeemer. It is my understanding that Saint Alphonsus started that particular order that being said he is an amazing Saint very powerful and clear on his words certainly will put the fear of God in you. He helped me root out some really stubborn sins of the flesh and taught me well. Thanks for the story. May our Lord Jesus Christ bless this Holy man of God.

  7. This book was AMAZING! I had seen an interview with him on EWTN. WHAT A PRIEST and what a way to touch souls and bring them to the Lord. God Bless Father Carney!

  8. I met Father Carney in Scottsdale about two weeks ago! He blessed me and I am truly grateful for this! what an amazing experience and a wonderful priest! God Bless Father Carney!

Comments are closed.

Popular on OnePeterFive

Share to...