(Image: Bonn, home of the Secretariat of the German Bishops’ Conference)
On 14 February, Steve Skojec reported on his own attempts to receive, in justice, some clarifications – specific and unambiguous ones – concerning steps now to be taken by the Archdiocese of Newark with regard to the outspoken and conservative Catholic priest, Father Peter West. (My family has known Father West personally and has cherished him for his gentleness and radiant kindness). As it now turns out, however, the speaker for the Archdiocese evaded and then declined to give any further details as to the standing “protocols” and the canonical grounds upon which Father West will now be dealt with.
A similar experience of evasion and denial of access has also just come to me, but this time from another place: Germany.
During my extensive reporting on the new 1 February German Bishops’ pastoral guidelines with regard to the “remarried” divorcees, I several times contacted (first on 2 February) the press speaker of the German Bishops’ Conference, Matthias Kopp, in order to acquire clarifications from him regarding some important details of the new doctrinal-pastoral guidelines. During our exchanges, I had essentially posed two important questions:
- Whether or not the divorced and “remarried” persons who were to receive the proposed “accompaniment” and “discernment” concerning their possible having licit access to the Sacraments of Penance and of the Holy Eucharist may now be counseled by a pastoral caretaker who is a layman. (If this were to be the case, would it not also raise serious questions about a layman’s effective jurisdiction in the Catholic Church?)
- Whether or not the local priest must then accept those assisted individual decisions of conscience and thus admit those individuals to the Sacraments, even if the priest himself might have, in his own conscience, moral objections to those subjective decisions. (The Austrian Bishop, Andreas Laun, just recently wrote about a German priest with exactly this kind of difficulty and moral objection.)
Additionally, I asked Mr. Kopp whether there will be a kind of formal process where the final decision with regard to the access to the Sacraments will be written down in the registry of the parish, similar to how it would now be properly done with those faithful persons who have received an ecclesial declaration of nullity of their marriage from its inception.
I had hoped to receive from Mr. Kopp – the official press speaker for the German Bishops’ Conference – an official and unambiguous, clear and affirmative response.
The background for these specifically posed questions is – as I have already reported – that the German pastoral guidelines only speak of “pastoral caretakers” with regard to the “process of discernment.” But, according to the Catholic Church’s Law (Canon 519), a “pastoral caretaker” may also be a layman officially working for the individual diocese. (The more inclusive definition of “pastoral caretaker” had been earlier pointed out to me by an expert of the German Bishops’ Conference, Dr. Michael Feil.) The other reason for my questions is the fact that the new pastoral guidelines now say – even in an insistent way – that “the decision [of the “remarried” divorcees] to receive the Sacraments must be respected,” [my emphasis] with finality, as if it were a final declaration of nullity.
After several days of going back and forth over formalities – for I had, in Mr. Kopp’s eyes, not yet properly given a sufficient amount of my personal contact information – Mr. Kopp finally gave me one officially responsive statement, and he further requested that I either publish it in full and unabridged, or otherwise first receive his approval if I choose to use only excerpts of his response. He also said that he rejects my own depiction of the situation according to which there is chaos now spreading in the Catholic Church in Germany.
Here is his statement:
- Pope Francis says in his post-synodal Apostolic document Amoris Laetitia: “The Church possesses a solid body of reflection concerning mitigating factors and situations. Hence it can no longer simply be said that all those in any “irregular” situation are living in a state of mortal sin and are deprived of sanctifying grace.” (AL no. 301)
- This [AL quote] has as a direct consequence that 915 CIC [Code of Canon Law] is not any more presumptively applicable to all those persons who live in so-called “irregular” situations: “Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or the declaration of a penalty, as well as others who obstinately persist in manifest grave sin, are not to be admitted to communion.” [Can. 915 CIC]
- Fundamentally, the right to the reception of the Sacraments is valid: “Any baptized person not prohibited by law can and must be admitted to Holy Communion.” (Can. 912 CIC)
- As a restriction, there remains the judgment of conscience in the individual case: “A person who is conscious of grave sin is not to celebrate Mass or receive the Body of the Lord without previous sacramental confession unless there is a grave reason and there is no opportunity to confess; in this case the person is to remember the obligation to make an act of perfect contrition which includes the resolution of confessing as soon as possible.” (Can. 916 CIC) [my emphasis]
As the reader may easily see, Mr. Kopp has not at all answered my specific questions. Thus I asked him again to answer those questions, saying that I know of German priests who now worry whether they might be pressured to accept the personal individual decision of conscience of a “remarried” person, even though it goes against the priest’s own conscience. (Here, once more – as Dr. Edward Peters also again told us on 14 February – I would point to the risk and danger of a grave penalty for, in any way, soliciting the violation of the Sixth Commandment in Confession (Can. 1387), which is itself a grave sin.)
On 14 February, Mr. Kopp answered me one last time, saying that he prefers not to say more than what he had already said.
In my last e-mail to him, I had earnestly requested of him simply to answer my questions – “dubia” – with a simple yes or no; and, while writing it, I was reminded of the Four Cardinals’ own dubia! I also told Mr. Kopp that ambiguous vagueness is not pastoral, and not to clarify such matters is not manly. (I did mention the parallel to Pope Francis’ silence with regard to the dubia.) I essentially said to him: say what your intentions and plans are and then deal with the potentially opposing voices as they come to present themselves politely. But, to leave a whole country – Germany – in a confused state as to who may likely and officially now counsel those “remarried” divorcees; and as to whether a priest must then accept the decision of conscience of these “accompanied” couples with regard to the Sacraments – whatever their decision may be – is itself a grave and negligent omission.
After Mr. Kopp’s final answer to me, I directly turned to two German prelates: first to Cardinal Reinhard Marx – President of the German Bishops’ Conference – and then to Bishop Stefan Oster of Passau. The former did not respond at all to my questions; the second is currently traveling, I was told.
What I should have asked Mr. Kopp, but failed to do, is the following: when mentioning “all those in any ‘irregular’ situation” with regard to their possible and permitted access to the Sacraments, does this apply to cohabitating partners, and even to homosexual partners, as well? This matter is of great concern also to the German psychiatrist, Dr. Christian Spaemann – son of the esteemed Professor Robert Spaemann – who wrote an article in which he points to the danger that the German Bishops’ recent undefined reference to “irregular situations” might now include Communion for people in all kinds of irregular relationships – thus promoting a moral relativism which would then undermine the Catholics sacramental order altogether.
We shall now fittingly keep insisting, however, that Pope Francis himself needs to stop bringing the Catholic Church into a deeply uprooted state of confusion and demoralization. Because, as even Mr. Kopp acknowledges in his official response to me: the new German pastoral guidelines derive from Amoris Laetitia and the mind of the pope.
This is what happens when those counting on an ignorant sheepfold find out that they have overestimated their own command of the issues. Lack of a coherent response to these inquiries reveals the absence of alignment with the Spirit which guides the Church with unchanging teachings, not novelties. I feel sorry for them. I will feel sorrier for them when they find out, when faithful Catholics withdraw their financial support, that the faithful Catholics are the one’s who actually keep the Church into the black. It is something like what the socialists find out when they discover that eventually when you spend other people’s money it runs out. Almost time to cut them off.
It depends how important they are to Soros, but his coffers can dry up if/when PF resigns or dies.
Hi Ann – Soros is good at fighting little fires. Francis is playing with matches while dousing himself with spiritual gasoline, and once he sets himself on fire, Soros, will find out his resources are inadequate to the task of bringing that fire under control. Soros might as well get use to dancing in the flames he has courted his entire life, eternity awaits.
I hope you’re right!
Hi h – If you are a hermit, I envy you. In the grand scheme of things people like Soros are really pipsqueaks that pump themselves up with self delusions of grandeur. He is being humbled as the globalist agenda crumbles before his eyes.
Again, I hope you’re right.
Thank you for all your efforts to seek out definitive and unambiguous answers. The responses (as well as lack of responses) you have been given are telling. You have asked the questions that have needed to be asked.
‘You have asked the questions that have needed to be asked’………and have received nothing but obfuscation in return!
What’s a cassock-lifter
The correct question is…what’s a cassock? most of these who run around orbiting PF haven’t worn it since…ever.
But they do wear the most expensive suits out there. Talk about humility!
Anyone else notice that clericalism, rank clericalism in fact, is making a splendid comeback under Pope Francis? It’s pray, pay, and obey — and don’t ask pesky questions – time all over again!
By all means pray, obey as Mary’s exhortation at Cana ‘do whatever He tells you’.
As for pay, contribute to faithful priests only.
As for Germany it is the church tax, to a national church in apostasy?
There must be some wriggle room there to avoid paying
These bishops think are so out of touch. They don’t care about their flock, they care about themselves. I heard a lecture with Bishop Morlino right before the synod about this. Its on line At Institue of Catholic Culture. He said that adulterers approaching the alter would be a lie.
But where is he now? Where are bishops standing up for US?
We just got a new bishop in Arllington. He has said not one word. Neither has outgoing bishop. I find them all cowardly. They have grown soft. They are managers, MUST lack a prayer life. THey basically think of this as a job.
I’m so disillusioned I could plotz
I pray that the Church can determine if the Holy Father is a formal heretic or not, given the fact he is an obvious material heretic.
Absolutely Daniel. I have mentioned to my close friends that one can easily demonstrate material heresy in Francis. If the formal state can be demonstrated, it begs the question what was his state before March 2013? Is it probable that such a state was acquired after March 2013? Or is it more likely he has held such views for a longer time?
Bishop Stefan Oster is one of the few Catholic Bishops still left in Germany so if he does not respond in an orthodox fashion I fear the worst.
The only criteria these dopes are relying on are subjective feelings.
Do what thou feeleth like is the whole of their law.
You didn’t really expect a straight answer from a liberal Catholic?
Dr. Hickson I hope you can tell us something about Müller’s new book as most of us are clueless on German 😉
Yes, I shall do so on Monday – the day when the book is released! Thank you.
Kudos to Maike Hickson for being so determined to clarify a situation in the Church – in Germany and elsewhere – that has become utterly chaotic.
ORGANIZED Christianity’s BIG Churches are MOSTLY Pharisaic INSTITUTIONS. They are mostly man-made, hence deficiencies and corruptions are abundant.
LOOK AT Jesus The Lord ONLY and learn from HIM. BE IN the Church but not necessarily of the Church BUT of The Lord, for mostly the Churches are man-made.
JUMPING out of The Church is as foolish or WISE as one jumping out of one’s own God-given SKIN. REMAIN INSIDE and BEAR WITNESS TO THE DEATH AND RESURRECTION OF JESUS THE LORD. Here lies OUR GLORY to BELONG to The Lord..
Jesus The Lord went on PROMOTING more and more People to Apostleship: 12 – make the original group, then the 72 and later individuals DIRECTLY CALLED BY THE LORD EVEN AFTER HIS RESURRECTION, like SAUL who became PAUL, considered the GREATEST APOSTLE. BUT The Church or better the Churches for they are DIVIDED INTO TOO MANY, what do they do? THEY, make only BISHOPS and through them, try to CONQUER THE WORD. Are the BISHOPS true APOSTLES of THE LORD in PRACTICE?
Let us learn from the true APOSTLES of Jesus The Lord as we have them in : in THE DIVINE and THE SEHION Retreat Centres, Kerala, INDIA. Find the details on GOOGLE.
THE DIVINE has also BRANCHES in :
USA :
CHICAGO
VincentianHouse, 1027 Twin Oaks Street, Bensenville IL, 60106, USA
Phone001 6304225236
WASHINGTON
PrayerCentre, 426, Route 57 West, Washington, NJ 07882, USA
Phone0019088359989Email $ Webhttp://www.divinenj.org/
UK:
DivineRetreat Centre, St. Augustine Abbey, St. Augustine’s Road, Ramsgate, CT119PA,Kent, UK
Phone00441843586904Email $ Webhttp://divineuk.org/
ITALY
ROME:
PadriVincenziani, Via Gregorio VII, 172 / B2, 00165, Roma (RM), Italy.Phone00390639674005C, ITALY
BERLIN:
ExerzitienzentrumDer Goettlichen Barmherzigkeit,St. Clemens Kirche, Stresemann Str. 66 a, 10963,Berlin, GERMANY
Phone00493026367698Email $ Webwww. vinzentinerberlin.com
FREUDENSTADT:
HausSt.Vinzenz, Lindenstrasse 18, 72250 Freudenstadt, GERMANY
Phone004974419125763Email $ Webwww.vez-fds.de
RAVENGIERSBURG:
VinzentinerHaus, Hauptstrasse 29, 55471 – Ravengiersburg, GERMANY
Phone0049 67619759668
AUSTRIA:
VinzentinerHaus, Zanaschkagasse 12/30/15-16, 1120, Wien, AUSTRIA
Phone004312319809Email $ Webwww.vinzentiner.at
AUSTRALIA
SHENTONPARK :
VincentianAshram, St. Aloysius Parish, 84 Keightley Road, WA 6008, Shenton Park,AUSTRALIA
Phone0061 93815383
PERTH:
VincentianHouse, Holy Family Church, Lot 375, Alcock Street, Maddington, 6109, Perth,AUSTRALIA
Phone0061 894931703
SOMERSBY:
DivineRetreat Centre, 160 Hensons Road, Somersby 2250, NSW, Australia
Phone0061243721598Email $ [email protected]
http://www.divineretreatcentre.org.auCountryAUSTRALIA
CANADA:
TORONTO
DivineRetreat Centre, Vincentian Prayer Centre, 69 William Street, Toronto, ON, M9N2G6, CANADA
Phone0016479494932Email $ Webwww.divinetoronto.org ; http://www.facebook.com/drctoronto,CA...
LIMA:
ParroquiaPadre Damian De Molokai, Mz “C” Lote – 23, Sector Ensenada – Puente Piedra,Lima 22, PERU
Phone0511 5510361CountryPeru
BANGALORE:
VincentianAshram, 29 Prakruthi Township, 1st Main, P.B. No 4326, Babusahib Palaya,Banglore, 560043, Karnataka, INDIA
Phone080 25603252, 25603748Email $ Webwww.logosretreatcentre.com
POTTA:
VincentianHouse, Potta, 680 722, Chalakkudy, Thrissur Dt., Kerala, INDIA
Phone0480 2708714Email $ Webhttp://www.pottaashram.com/
UGANDA
ENTEBBE:
VincentianFathers, Centenary Vincentian House, P.O. Box No. 200, Entebbe, Uganda, EastAfrica.Phone00256 414320242, UGANDA
MITEMULA:
St.Vincent’s Seminary, Mitemula, P.B No. 606, Masaka, Uganda, EastAfrica.Phone00256 780403553, UGANDA
MASAKA:
VincentianFathers, Divine Mercy Renewal Centre, Kabulassoke, P.B.No. 613, Masaka, Uganda,East Africa
Phone00256 715955050, UGANDA
KAYUNGA:
DePaul Boys Home, Kayunga, Masaka, Post Box No. 606, Uganda, East Africa
Phone00256775885634, UGANDA
KAMPALA:
VincentianRetreat Centre, Nzangi, P.B. No. 23, Kyengera, Kampala, Uganda, East Africa
Phone00256706214425, UGANDA
KENYA
KALIMONI:
St.Theresa’s Church, P.O. Box 141, 01001, Kalimoni, Juja, KENYA, East Africa,Phone 00254 701814252, KENYA
NAIROBI:
VincentianFathers, P.O. Box 25158, 00603, Lavington, Nairobi, Kenya, East Africa
Phone00254 726822406Email $ Webwww.vphnairobi.org, KENYA
THIKA,NAIROBI :
VincentianFathers, P.O. Box No.2009-01000, Thika, Nairobi Thika Highway, KENYA, EastAfrica
Phone00254706128129Email $ Webwww.vrcthika.org , KENYA
TANZANIA
KIGOMA:
VincentianFathers, P.O. Box No. 771, Kigoma, Tanzania, East Africa
Phone00255282803990, TANZANIA
UVINZA:
VincentianFathers, P.O. Box No. 17, Uvinza, Tanzania, East Africa.Phone00255 755000035,TANZANIA
VIKINDU:
VincentianFathers, Jesus Town, Vikindu, P.O. Box 14918, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, EastAfrica
Phone00255 784940232, TANZANIA
MOSHI:
VincentianFathers, Moshi, 7575, Tanzania, East Africa.Phone00255 682373706, TANZANIA
KENYA
KISUMU : Vincentian Prayer House, Buoye, Kisumu, Kenya, EastAfrica
Phone00254 722961956, KENYA
• Edit• Reply•Share ›
LOOKING at the DARK side of the Church we lose our FAITH. HENCE LOOK ONLY AT JESUS THE LORD IN THE CHURCH.
Needless to say that there is one point where conscience cannot play a role – those who refuse to pay church tax are to be refused the sacraments without any exception (at least this is what the bishops proclaim, many priests are mercifully more sensible). Alas, refusing to pay is still a big taboo amongst German Catholics, even amongst those who have come to realise that most bishops of the country are no longer Catholic, so the bishops can easily frighten them into shutting up and paying.